causal

Distinguishing quality signals from aesthetic selection

Just as a sweating performer at a concert may sweat because the performance demands it rather than because audiences like the sweat, extreme traits may be at performance limits because the aesthetic display requires it, not because the trait signals quality; the special hypothesis requiring extra evidence is that a trait-quality correlation reflects a benefit other than the benefit of beauty itself.

causalpending

Speaker

Richard Prum

Evidence Quote

“the special hypothesis — the one that demands specific evidence — is that the correlation is actually a result of the relation between the signal and some other kind of benefit, other than the benefit of beauty.”

Source

Richard Prum— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:26:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...