factual

Efficiency gap presupposes a correct seat count

The efficiency gap measure, though simple to compute and capturing something real about wasted votes, is flawed because it implicitly posits a right answer for how many seats a given popular vote should yield—placing it in the same genre as proportional representation—so a perfectly even state would score badly despite no gerrymandering.

factualpending

Speaker

Jordan Ellenberg

Evidence Quote

“it does kind of seem to posit that there's some right answer to how many legislative seats there should be, given a certain popular vote”

Source

151 | Jordan Ellenberg on the Mathematics of Political Boundaries— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:48 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...