normative

Withholding a Cure for Evil Would Be Incoherent

If we ever had a genuine cure for psychopathy/evil (a pill or stimulation that turns sadistic killers into remorseful normal people), maintaining retributive ethics would force us to withhold the cure as punishment—but that would make no moral sense, exactly as it would be senseless to deny curative surgery to someone whose brain tumor was causing violent compulsions; the only coherent stance is to cure rather than punish.

normativepending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“it would be like denying the person with the brain tumor that was causing him to act out violently a surgery we knew would cure him”

Source

360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:19:39 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...