A recent JAMA meta-analysis found that placebos were as good as antidepressants for mild or ordinary outpatient depression, but antidepressants did significantly better for severe/major depression. Menand calls the study odd for three reasons. It tested only one drug, Paxil, out of about 25 antidepressants on the market. It pooled only about 700 patients, against millions of users. And its severity split is hard to square mechanistically: if altering brain chemistry helps major depression, it obviously does something.

factualpending

Speaker

Louis Menand

Evidence Quote

“it was a very small sample size although it was a meta-analysis... about 700 patients in the meta-analysis”

Source

Louis Menand on Psychiatry 05/31/2010— EconTalk
Created: 10/29/2026, 7:34:04 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...