factual

Brain In A Vat Possible If It Has Perception-Action Loops

We could be brains in a vat without contradicting embodied or extended cognition, provided the vat supplies something equivalent to a body—possibilities for action and for offloading mental work onto an alterable environment; what matters most for cognition is perception-action loops, and the vat would just be a different physics for the same reality.

factualpending

Speaker

Andy Clark

Evidence Quote

“it's what you can do with perception action loops that i think really matters most here those i think are super essential to cognition what brains are are the mediators of perception action loops”

Source

322 - Predicting Reality— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:16:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...