causal
Fine-tunings are evidence for naturalism, not theism
Carroll's central rebuttal of design: the fine-tunings only enable complex, adaptive, information-gathering physical systems, which are required for life under naturalism but not under theism—God, unbound by physics, could attach minds to any configuration whatsoever; therefore the fact that constants are precisely amenable to physics-based life is actually evidence for naturalism rather than theism.
causalpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“God could have made life no matter what the constants of nature were... He could attach individual souls or essences or minds to any configuration of stuff he wanted.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:26 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...