factual

Pointing Theorem Fails for Infinite Groups

The theorem that not everyone can be more pointed-at than pointing fails for infinitely many people; with countably many people each holding one dollar, you can arrange a pattern of passing dollars (mapping the Nth train car to the Nth hotel room) so that afterward everyone has infinitely many dollars while each paid out only one.

factualpending

Speaker

Joel David Hamkins

Evidence Quote

“What you need is for each person to be attached to, you know, one of the train cars or something. So, think of everyone as coming from Hilbert's train, but also think of them as fitting into Hilbert's Hotel. So, just have everyone on the Nth car give all their money to the person who ends up in the Nth room.”

Source

Joel David Hamkins— Lex Fridman Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:33:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...