causal

Economics Shifted from Emergent View to Mechanical Map

Economics drifted from a bottom-up, emergent, biological view of human interaction—exemplified by Adam Smith and Hayek's 'Use of Knowledge in Society,' which treat the economy as a complex ecosystem we cannot fully understand—to a top-down, controllable, mechanical view beginning with Samuelson's 1948 Foundations of Economic Analysis, which mathematized and linearized economic life into a system of equations to be manipulated, leading economists to see themselves as priest-engineers who can move people like pieces on a chessboard, exactly the 'man of system' Smith warned against in 1759.

causalpending

Speaker

Russ Roberts

Evidence Quote

“the change goes from a bottom-up perception, which tends--which is, almost by definition to be observed--to a top-down one, which is to be, then, controlled. And the economist then sees him- or herself as an engineer/priest”

Source

Iain McGilchrist on the Divided Brain and the Master and His Emissary— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:28 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...