factual

Extremizing Diverse Independent Estimates

When advisers each offer the same probability (e.g., 70%) but draw on diverse, independent sources of evidence, the mathematically correct aggregate is more extreme than 70%—because each estimate carries incremental information—whereas if they are clones drawing on identical information, the answer stays 70%; the IARPA extremizing algorithm exploited this and outperformed 99% of individual superforecasters.

factualpending

Speaker

Philip Tetlock

Evidence Quote

“if the advisers are all saying 70% but they are drawing on diverse sources of information, it's a little counterintuitive but the answer is going to be quite a bit more extreme than 70%”

Source

Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...