factual

Numbers may be a useful human shortcut, not fundamental

Drawing on Hartry Field's Science Without Numbers, the mathematics in our theories (such as fields, which we never directly observe but infer from their effects on particles) may be intermediate storage steps in our heads rather than fundamental features of reality; Field reconstructed Newtonian gravity with no numbers at all, suggesting numbers are a handy human shortcut reflecting how our brains work, so aliens might use them or might find something else far more useful.

factualpending

Speaker

Daniel Whiteson

Evidence Quote

“as an exercise, he went through and developed a theory of gravity, so Newtonian, not general relativity, Newtonian gravity without any numbers at all... it's just a point that, like, well, you could do this without numbers.”

Source

334 | Daniel Whiteson on the Physics of and by Aliens— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:21:32 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...