factual

Bettencourt-West scale theory's three assumptions are debatable

Bettencourt and West's theory of scale rests on three assumptions—that cities are optimized (debatable, since they are not), that they are space-filling networks (but they exclude roads and sewer lines), and that the relevant networks are social networks based on total human population rather than land area or urban morphology—so roadways don't necessarily predict use because parks have heavy social, commercial, and civic use with few roads.

factualpending

Speaker

Catherine Brinkley

Evidence Quote

“They base their scale approximations on human population, total number. And the networks they say are social networks. So part of that is that you can have a roadway, but it doesn't necessarily predict use because places, parks for example, have a lot of use, a lot of social interactions, not a lot of roads”

Source

197 | Catherine Brinkley on the Science of Cities— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:06 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...