factual

Academia selects on brilliance, not kindness

Top research institutions select faculty almost entirely on research brilliance and accomplishment, caring essentially nothing about whether candidates are kind, generous, or good teachers; therefore any correlation between academic success and unkindness is better explained as a filtering effect than as success grinding people down, and academic success should if anything make generosity easier.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“the extent to which hiring committees could not possibly care less about your personal qualities, as long as you're good at doing research would be astonishing... a person was being considered and someone else said, 'Well, you know that person's kind of a jerk.' And as soon as they said it, everyone was like, 'Who cares? What is their research?'”

Source

AMA | November 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...