causal

Motivation Differences Confound Cognition Tests

Apparent species differences in cognition can actually reflect differences in motivation and orientation toward the world rather than underlying ability: orangutans observe a problem patiently before acting while chimps and bonobos immediately grab and manipulate it, behaviors driven by their social ecology—in competitive social groups, you must grab food quickly or lose it—so scientists must be careful that task-engagement style does not masquerade as cognitive capacity.

causalpending

Speaker

Erica Cartmill

Evidence Quote

“some of these things about the social and physical environments that species have been adapted to live in can really change the way they're inclined to engage with the tasks that we as scientists give them.”

Source

346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:02 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...