definition

Reasoning Is Motivated By Peer Trust

Psychological reasoning is not formal logic but the generation of reasons for what we think and feel, driven by a desire to be considered trustworthy to our peers; reasons must be 'plausible' in the sense that our most trusted social network would judge them reasonable, which is why beliefs are calibrated to social acceptance rather than to truth.

definitionpending

Speaker

David McRaney

Evidence Quote

“when it comes to reasoning, in a psychological sense, it's not the big R reason--the propositions and logic... Reasoning, psychologically speaking is just coming up with reasons for what you think, feel, and believe. And, those reasons are motivated by a desire to... be considered trustworthy to your peers.”

Source

David McRaney on How Minds Change— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:32:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...