causal

Free will compatible with determinism via unknown initial conditions

The phrase 'could have done otherwise' is consistent with a deterministic universe obeying equations of motion, because free will is a useful concept only since human beings are too complicated for us to know their microscopic initial conditions; the right question is whether, among all microscopic configurations compatible with the macroscopic description we have, some would act one way and some another — if yes, that corresponds in higher-level vocabulary to 'you could have acted differently.'

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“the point is that we don't know the initial conditions in the real world... The reason why free will, if you believe it is, if you're a compatibilist, if you believe it's a useful concept is because human beings are so complicated that we don't know their initial conditions.”

Source

AMA | December 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...