factual

Borda Method Violates Irrelevant Alternatives

Borda's averaged-rank voting method avoids cycling but introduces dependence on irrelevant alternatives: removing or disqualifying a non-winning candidate can reverse the relative standing of the remaining candidates—like choosing steak over chicken but switching to chicken once fish is added to the menu—so it merely substitutes one form of manipulability for another.

factualpending

Speaker

Leo Katz

Evidence Quote

“somebody going into a restaurant and he's choosing between chicken and steak; and he chooses the steak; and then he's informed that there's also fish on the menu, and then he says, 'Well, now I'm going to have the chicken instead.'”

Source

Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...