normative
British Empire Critique Requires Counterfactual
Anyone arguing the British Empire was unmitigatedly bad must show that outcomes—for example India's economic development—would have been more benign and faster under Mughal rule or the Indian princes who would otherwise have remained in power; without that explicit counterfactual the moral judgment is incomplete.
normativepending
Speaker
Neil FergusonEvidence Quote
“i've based all of my work on a deal with the reader that if i'm making an argument of a causal nature i'll i'll make the the counterfactual explicit”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:09:23 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...