factual

Self-Refutation Objection To Eliminativism

The classic objection to eliminative materialism is that it is self-refuting—'you believe there are no beliefs,' 'you desire to convince us there are no desires'—a cheap shot that is nonetheless a serious problem; Rosenberg wrote the history book partly to compartmentalize the position so its value could be shown without first solving this self-refutation problem.

factualpending

Speaker

Alex Rosenberg

Evidence Quote

“'You desire to convince us that there are no desires. You are refuting yourself out of your own mouth.' Well, that's a very, on the one hand, easy cheap shot; on the other hand, a serious issue for all of us eliminative materialists.”

Source

125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:50 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...