normative

Smoke-Filled Rooms Produced Better Candidates

We arguably had better elected officials when party bosses ('guys with cigars in smoke-filled rooms') picked centrist candidates likely to win the general election, because direct democratic primaries reward candidates who appeal to the passionate fringe of a party rather than the broad electorate—raising the question of whether a party-picks-candidate (parliamentary) model would yield more sensible outcomes despite its own instability.

normativepending

Speaker

Lloyd Blankfein

Evidence Quote

“we had better outcomes on elected officials when guys with cigars met ... in smoke-filled rooms and picked a candidate who they thought would win the general election”

Source

473 - Money Power And Moral Failure— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:09:18 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...