causal

Uganda Plan Would Have Failed Without Land Continuity

Herzl's openness to the 'Uganda Plan' was his greatest mistake, because a Jewish state succeeds partly through the experiential continuity of living where biblical events occurred—seeing ancient place-names on highway exit signs creates a sense of homecoming; Jews had prayed for 2,000 years to return to Zion specifically, not merely to have any home, so a state elsewhere would have failed for lack of immigrants.

causalpending

Speaker

Daniel Gordis

Evidence Quote

“Jews were not praying for thousands of years to have a home. Jews were praying for thousands of years to go home to Zion.”

Source

Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:13 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...