normative
Utility As A Sum Over Individuals Makes No Sense
As a moral constructivist, Carroll objects to utilitarianism on two levels: it fails to systematize his actual moral intuitions (as the repugnant conclusion and organ-harvesting cases show), and more fundamentally the very idea of utility as a sum over the sub-utilities of individuals makes no sense because there is no good way to compare utilities across different people; while any rule can formally be cast as maximizing some number, the specific feature of adding utility across persons is an unjustified starting point.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“It's the way of defining utility as a sum over sub utilities of individuals. That just seems to make no sense whatsoever to me. I don't see why that should be true.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:40 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...