factual

Mary's Room and Physicalism Tension

There is tension in the physicalist response to Mary's Room: the view that 'of course Mary learns something new, her neurons had never fired that way before' may miss the point of the thought experiment, since both Goff and physicalists like Dennett seem to agree that physicalism requires Mary to NOT learn anything new.

factualpending

Speaker

Peter Newell

Evidence Quote

“Goff and some of the audience members seemed adamant that this completely misses the point of the thought experiment, and furthermore other physicalists, such as Daniel Dennet, seem to find it crucial to argue that Mary does NOT learn anything new.”

Source

AMA | May 2025— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:48 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...