normative

Extended Mind Boundary Is Partly Moral Decision

Whether to count external resources as part of the mind is not settled by functional similarity alone, which Clark sees as a stalemate; it becomes a moral or ethical decision, because treating people with dementia who rely on smartphones or their environment as merely their unaided biological capacities would do them an injustice, just as it would for someone with a well-fitted prosthetic limb.

normativepending

Speaker

Andy Clark

Evidence Quote

“we'd be doing ourselves a certain kind of injustice if we treated people, say, with mild dementia that rely very much on a smartphone or on their home environment in just that kind of way”

Source

235 | Andy Clark on the Extended and Predictive Mind— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...