factual

Causation operates within levels, not between them

Carroll rejects both downward and upward causation: causal efficacy occurs within a well-defined level of description (quantum fields, chemistry, or people and chairs), while relationships between levels are supervenience, explanatory, coarse-graining, or emergence relations rather than cause-and-effect in the sense Judea Pearl would recognize.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“I don't think the causation is the right way to think about it, not in the sense of cause and effect that Judea Pearl would ever care about”

Source

AMA | December 2020— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:45 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...