causal

NANOGrav's 11-Year Signal Was Jupiter Ephemeris Error

Around 2015, NANOGrav's 11-year data showed a signal resembling a gravitational wave background, raising hopes of scooping LIGO, but it turned out to be due to solar system ephemeris errors—an error in Jupiter's mass/position perturbing the solar system barycenter, with 11 years roughly being Jupiter's orbital period—and the apparent signal disappeared once corrective software was applied.

causalpending

Speaker

Chiara Mingarelli

Evidence Quote

“there was some sort of error in the position in massive Jupiter that was perturbing the solar system barycenter, and once my colleague at JPL, Michele Vallisneri, wrote this software to correct for this, the signal went away.”

Source

212 | Chiara Mingarelli on Searching for Black Holes with Pulsars— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:12:04 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...