definition

Moral Luck And Judgment Of Greatness

Williams's concept of moral luck shows that how we judge a person depends partly on outcomes outside their control (as with Gauguin, whose abandonment of family is forgiven only because he proved a great painter), which clashes with the modern intuition that morality should be judged by motive alone, while more ancient notions hold people accountable for the wisdom and ability to anticipate whether their actions produce good or harm.

definitionpending

Speaker

Larissa MacFarquhar

Evidence Quote

“whether you are able to in fact do good is a result of luck of various kinds, like your own ability, the situation in the world that you find yourself in”

Source

Larissa MacFarquhar— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:29:46 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...